Colour Pacifier 4 Pack vs Holiday Horse: Which to Choose
By BIBS | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Buying Guides
Deciding between the BIBS Colour Pacifier 4 Pack and the Holiday Horse single pacifier? This guide breaks down the key differences to help you choose the right soother for your baby.
Quick answer
Choose the Colour Pacifier 4 Pack if you want multiple nipple shapes and great value; pick the Holiday Horse for a single, classic round pacifier with a playful design.
Nipple shape and baby preference
The 4 Pack includes three nipple shapes: round, symmetrical, and anatomical. This variety lets you test which shape your baby prefers without buying separate pacifiers. The Holiday Horse only offers a classic round nipple, which mimics natural breastfeeding. If your baby is picky, the 4 Pack gives you flexibility; if they already like round nipples, the Holiday Horse is a straightforward choice.
Value and quantity
The 4 Pack costs $15.15 (normally $21.95) for four pacifiers, making it a budget-friendly option for parents who need backups or want to try different shapes. The Holiday Horse is a single pacifier at $4.77. If you only need one spare or want to test the round nipple first, the single is more economical. For longer-term use or multiple stashes, the 4 Pack offers better value.
Decision rules
- Need variety or backups?: Choose the Colour 4 Pack. It gives you four pacifiers with three nipple shapes, so you can test preferences and have spares ready.
- Want a single, classic option?: Go with the Holiday Horse. It's one pacifier with a round nipple and a charming design, ideal for babies who already like that shape.
- Worried about materials?: Both pacifiers use natural rubber latex nipples and BPA-free shields, so material safety is consistent across options. Check your baby's latex sensitivity before choosing either option.
Product facts
- Colour Pacifiers 4 Pack - Ivory/Sand/Vanilla/Dark Oak: The BIBS Colour 4 Pack offers three different nipple shapes: round, symmetrical, and anatomical, in natural rubber latex. This variety helps you discover which nipple shape your baby accepts best without buying multiple separate pacifiers.
Colour Pacifiers 4 Pack - Ivory/Sand/Vanilla/Dark Oak - Colour Holiday Horse Pacifier - Vanilla: The Holiday Horse features a classic round nipple designed to mimic natural breastfeeding, made from natural rubber latex. If your baby already prefers a round nipple, this single pacifier is a simple, cost-effective choice with a fun horse design.
Colour Holiday Horse Pacifier - Vanilla
Which one fits your needs?
Best for
- Parents who want to try multiple nipple shapes affordably
- Babies who are picky about pacifier shape and need variety
Not for
- Parents who only need one spare pacifier and prefer a specific design
